Thursday, September 17, 2009

Demos: Part 2, Free Monkeys, Banchos, and Wii-views  

.
.
Games: A while ago, I complained about demos that failed to impress, and wondered why it seemed so difficult for developers to accomplish what appears to be a fairly straightforward task.
.
(If you missed that particular rant, you can see it HERE.)
.
At the end of the piece, I invited developers to write in and school me if I was off-base, and one actually did. Talented game dude and all-around good guy Andrew Rubino dropped me a line not too long after my blog ran, and this is what he had to say:
.
In summary, making a demo is harder than it seems, especially for some games. A demo for something like Gears of War would be relatively easy – have a couple combats and the player walks away with a good understanding of what the game is about. But a demo for something like Batman is harder, (something that I can see now that I’ve played the full game, which is awesome, btw).
.

.
At its heart, Batman is Metroid, which means it’s about exploring a large space and interacting with it in new ways. That’s difficult to capture in a demo where you can’t include enough areas to show that off.
.
Ideally, a demo gives players a good idea of what the game is about while at the same time enticing them to check out the full product. But Batman has a number of different gameplay systems going on – combat, stealth, platforming, exploration – and that makes it difficult to pick a slice of the game to demo that shows off everything. We had a similar problem with Argo when we discussed a demo: if we just use the first 20 minutes, then people will think we’re an action game with little story and we’re not. If we just show the section after that, then people will think we’re all talking and won’t see the cool combat system. And we can’t show both or the demo will be too large.
.

.
The first level/section of a game often makes a great demo, since that’s usually where you try to grab the player’s attention as well as explain all the different gameplay systems. But in addition to the previously mentioned problems, there’s also a more practical one – the first level is often the last to be implemented. So it might not be ready for prime time when a demo comes out. And while you could make a custom demo for your game, you might not have any time for it in your schedule.
.
So I guess what I’m saying is don’t be too hard on the developers that put out not-so-great demos. They aren’t easy.
.
Infinite thanks to Andrew for chiming in on the issue, and if any other developers out there would like to comment, please drop me a line anytime.
.
.
.
.

.
Games: Although I haven't tried it yet personally, Telltale Games and LucasArts are giving away the first installment of Tales of Monkey Island for FREE on International Talk Like A Pirate Day (also known as September 19th.) In addition, they're having a number of sales and price breaks on other titles. To download the free game or for more information, go HERE.
.
.
.
.

.
Games: Uber-publisher Atlus has just released a video for their upcoming PSP game, Kenka Bancho: Badass Rumble. I'm always up for a good brawler, and what’s not to love about eye lasers or kicking someone’s ass in a giant banana suit? Looks like a winner to me. Check it HERE. You'll giggle in a good way.
.
.
.
.

.
Games: Just completed my review of Muramasa: the Demon Blade… and it wasn't pretty. I can hardly wait for the fan mail I'll receive after this one. It hasn't gone live yet, but I'll post a link when it does.
.
In the meantime, you can check out my review of Cursed Mountain, also on the Wii. For those of you out there who are convinced I'm absolutely anti-Wii, I think this particular piece will give at least a modicum of proof to the contrary. I give credit where credit is due.
.
.

What next?

You can also bookmark this post using your favorite bookmarking service:

Related Posts by Categories



2 comments: to “ Demos: Part 2, Free Monkeys, Banchos, and Wii-views


  •  

    I'll be interested to see your review of Muramasa. So far I don't like it nearly as much as Odin Sphere. The main reason is the translation and story, which are both nowhere NEAR as good as Odin Sphere, but also I don't think the combat and character advancement systems are as good.

    Odin Sphere had a pretty clear idea about what it was, I think, in that it was a fairly dense, story-driven RPG with a 2D fighter combat system. Muramasa seems like it can't decide if its really an action game or an RPG, just like it can't decide if it really wants the story to matter or not. The audio-visual design remains sublimely gorgeous, but the actual plot and dialogue is nigh incoherent. I almost never have a clear idea who people are or why I'm doing what I'm doing... or even who I really am. Very disappointing, coming from the handsome narrative clarity of Odin Sphere. I also find the action somewhat difficult to follow since, unlike Odin Sphere, you're stuck on a single screen for every battle. And the forging and cooking systems are so thin, requiring no thought at all to create new items, you wonder why they were included. At least in Odin Sphere there was a system (difficult though it was) to master.


  •  

    Well, I just wrapped up my review of Muramasa and it's not very favorable to Vanillaware. I'll post a link to it when it goes live at GameCritics, but I think it's probably safe to say that the publisher probably won't be sending us any more free games. = (