Sunday, August 3, 2014

RetroReview: Monster Rancher Battle Card: Episode II - PlayStation  


Monster Rancher Battle Card: Episode II
Developer: Tecmo
Publisher: Tecmo
Platform: Sony PlayStation

Originally reviewed at @Gamecritics on September 22, 2000

Ten, or even five years ago, if you asked someone to play some cards, chances are they’d immediately think you might want to indulge in a game of Poker or Blackjack, or perhaps Fish if you weren’t of the high-stakes, risk-taking persuasion. However, in the last few years new ideas and concepts of how cards can be used and played with have come about, and it’s been a relative revolution in gaming circles ever since.

Starting with the immensely popular Magic: The Gathering fantasy cardgame, a hybrid was invented combining the fun, social aspect of traditional cards and the addicting collectability of trading cards. A huge number of companies have turned out similar games branching out into almost every possible direction based off of the incredible success the idea has achieved, and it’s been a boom since then. With cardgames featuring varied settings including Fantasy, Sci-Fi, comic book characters and even the ubiquitous and omnipotent Pokemon franchise, it’s hard to find a person who hasn’t seen what gamers have been doing with these little pieces of paper lately.

*credit: Gamespot

Taking the concept of playable and collectable cards one step further by bringing it to an electronic format, Tecmo brings us Monster Rancher Battle Cards. Based on their two other virtual pet/monster raising niche titles, Battle Cards takes the same previously established world and characters and gives them an entirely different style of play.

After turning on the Playstation, the game begins with a bit of introductory story and then you’re asked 20 questions regarding your personality. Based on your answers the computer assigns you a beginning team of 3 Monster cards and 50 of the appropriate matching Skill cards. The Monster cards represent your characters during a match, and the Skill cards are their attacks, defenses, special abilities or other various powers that can give effects during play. Your first real game is a fairly good tutorial session between yourself and your assistant, Cue, who serves to give you helpful hints during play. It takes no more than three or four turns of the tutorial to get the gist of how the game flows, and then you’re off and running.

The game’s rules and setup are quite simple. Matches take place between two players each having virtual decks of 50 cards and 3 Monster cards on each side of   the board. Players draw five cards at the start and are required to replenish their hand to 5 at the beginning of each turn if any cards have been used. Cards require “Guts” to play, and Guts are acquired by discarding cards from your hand, so the game becomes a balancing act of deciding which cards are valuable enough to keep for use and which are better used by converting to Guts. Also, the more powerful cards cost more Guts to activate so you can choose to save up for the expensive, earth-shattering attacks instead of the lower-cost piddling attacks, but you leave yourself open while stockpiling Guts, or it’s even possible for your opponent to steal your Guts before you can get the attack off. The match is won by either K.O.’ing   all three of your opponent’s monsters, or by making your opponent run out of cards so they are unable to draw. It’s a very elegant and easy-to-understand system yet one that allows for a huge amount of depth and customization between the large amount of Monsters you can choose and the equally large amount of Skill cards you can select.

*credit: Gamespot

The Monsters’ abilities and attacks are consistent with the two previous games, and the personality inherent in each creature carries over through each one’s selection of moves as well as various animations that occur as you attack and defend. There are a large number of available Monster types such as the Speed and Dodge types  like the feminine Pixie or the canine Tiger. If brute strength is more to your taste, there’s no shortage of those with larger creatures like the stony Golem or the whale-like Zilla.

Most Tecmo games in recent memory including the two Monster Rancher titles, the Deception series and Gallop Racer have all been on the low end of the spectrum graphically (with the Dead or Alive series being the sole exception) while maintaining an extremely high level of fun and replayability. Battle Cards follows suit. The graphics are very simple, clean affairs using static backgrounds and 2D hand-drawn art for the character portraits and Monsters. While the art itself is aesthetically appealing from a design perspective, the animation is a bit disappointing with only one or two frames for an entire attack and around three or four expressions total for the human characters. It’s very reminiscent of how most 16-bit RPGs looked, and while there’s nothing inherently wrong with it, it seems that they could have put a bit more effort into making it more smoothly animated and pleasing to the eye especially with the generally higher expectations of gamers today.

Another area Tecmo is famous (or rather, infamous) for is their longstanding tradition of shaky translations. Some of the banter between players both before and during matches don’t always make sense and some of the quotes seem mis-timed. For example, in the middle of a match an opponent will say  “Don’t draw cards” when it’s clearly your turn to draw and you’ve got 40 cards left. Also, some of the text on the cards aren’t very clear and can be confusing until the card is actually used. It’s nothing that ruins the game, but with such a generally solid title overall, it’s a shame to see corners cut that could so easily have been fixed with just a bit more work.

*credit: Gamespot

Despite the minor lack of polish on the translation and the underachiever goal-setting of the graphics team, it’s a worthwhile tradeoff for the game’s incredibly high addiction factor. You’ll be telling yourself “Just one more game” at three in the morning and finding that you stayed awake until four or five. Like the previous Monster Rancher titles, the AI provides some serious, mind-bending challenge once you get to the higher levels and it feels extremely satisfying to win a match when things come down to the wire. Getting the mix of cards in your deck right as well as forming the perfect team will keep you busy for far longer than the average title does, and if the game had included some (sorely missed) two-player head-to-head, you’d never leave the house. Still, despite the missing multi, it’s a deep and engrossing experience for one person. 

Like the other Rancher titles, Battle Cards is built for mastery in the long haul. This is a game that requires long hours and perseverance to complete but the reward of being able to consistently win matches and eventually beat the game is well worth it, and gives a true feeling of accomplishment. Overall, Battle Cards keeps the flavor, spirit and depth of the first two Monster Rancher titles while bringing an entirely new direction to the gameplay. It’s definitely a title Tecmo should be proud of, and it comes and highly recommended to fans of Monster Rancher or of fantasy cardgames in general. 

Rating: 8.5 out of 10


Notes: Criminy, could I have been more verbose? Reading this back, I want to cut at least a third of it out... SO talky. Jeez! Also, it's near-impossible to find good pics of this game online. Thank goodness Gamespot snapped a few back in the day...

That stuff aside, I'd love a new Monster Rancher that's been given a for-realsies update. , I think there's still loads of potential in the franchise, despite the last few entries being pretty  bankrupt, creatively. To be fair, I'm sure it was hard to come up with fresh takes on the game when they were trying to crank them out to meet demand, but there's no need to mass-produce 'em these days. The time is ripe for a ground-up reboot, I say.

What next?

You can also bookmark this post using your favorite bookmarking service:

Related Posts by Categories